Your front door works harder during the holidays than any other time of year. Guests are coming and going, packages are piling up, wreaths are hanging on it and the cold is pushing on it every night. If yours drags, rattles or lets in a draft, the holidays are when you notice it most.
Here is a simple inspection you can do in about ten minutes, how to tell a repair from a replacement, and the questions worth asking before you buy a new entry door.
The 10-minute front door check
Grab a flashlight and a dollar bill and work through this list:
- The light test. Close the door at night with the porch light on and the inside lights off. Look along the edges and the bottom. If you can see light, air is getting through.
- The dollar bill test. Close the door on a dollar bill in a few spots along the edge. If it slides out easily, the weatherstripping is not sealing.
- Open and close it. Does it drag on the floor or the frame? Do you have to lift or push it to latch?
- Lock it. The deadbolt should slide in smoothly. If you have to lean on the door to lock it, the door or frame has shifted.
- Check the bottom. Look at the bottom of the door and the threshold. Swelling, soft spots, rot or rust are signs of water damage.
- Look at the frame. Check the jamb for cracks, soft wood or gaps between the frame and the wall. If you are not sure what the jamb is, see our guide to the parts of an exterior door.
- Check the glass. If your door has glass, look for fog between the panes or failing seals around it.
- Step back and look at it from the street. Fading, peeling, dents and a dated style all matter when it is the first thing people see.
Repair or replace?
Not every problem means a new door. Here is how I would sort it out:
Usually a repair
- Worn weatherstripping on an otherwise solid door.
- A loose hinge screw or a strike plate that needs adjusting.
- A door sweep that is torn or missing.
Usually time to replace
- The door or frame is warped, so it will not seal no matter what you adjust.
- Rot or water damage at the bottom of the door, the threshold or the frame.
- Light around the edges even after new weatherstripping.
- Fogged or cracked glass in the door.
- The lock does not line up and adjusting it does not hold.
- The finish is failing and the door is still drafty. At that point you are paying to refinish a door that does not work.
If you are replacing the door because the frame has moved or rotted, replacing the frame at the same time matters. A new door hung in a bad frame will not seal for long.
What a new entry door gives you
- A tight seal. New weatherstripping, a new threshold and a door that sits square in its frame keep the cold out.
- Security. A door and lock that line up every time.
- Curb appeal. It is the first thing guests notice when they pull in the driveway.
- Easy operation. No lifting, pushing or slamming to get it closed.
Want more natural light in the entry? We put together ideas for front doors with glass.
What about a storm door?
When you replace your entry door with us, you can add a matching storm door in the same project. It adds another layer against wind and weather and lets you open the main door for light and air when the weather is nice. We install storm doors as part of an entry door replacement, not by themselves.
Questions to ask before you buy
Whoever you hire, these are worth asking:
- Who does the install? Your own crew or a subcontractor?
- Are you replacing the frame and threshold, or just the door slab?
- How is the door insulated and sealed around the frame?
- What does the warranty cover, and for how long? Is installation covered too?
- How long is the lead time, and how long does the install take?
- What happens to the trim inside and out?
Our answers: our own crews install, we look at the whole opening, and every door installation is backed by our lifetime warranty.
Timing for the holidays
Entry doors are ordered to fit your opening, so there is a lead time between the final measure and install. Ask your consultant for the current lead time. Most installs are done in a day. If it cannot happen before the holidays, getting the estimate now means you are on the schedule early for the new year.
Make a great first impression
Homeowners rate us 4.8 from 600+ Google reviews. See our entry door options or schedule a free estimate.


